Hip-Hop is, and always has been, a young man’s game. As the giants of the 90′s enter middle age, they face an almost impossible landscape in which to continue making music. Trends and styles have changed, not necessarily for the better. So what’s a rapper to do? Recruit Chris Brown and Polow the Don in hope of keeping up with the youth? Or blow off record sales and the mainstream and make something that’s the natural progression of a past artistic portfolio?
Q-Tip’s choice on his latest album, The Renaissance, should come as no surprise, as Tribe and the Zulu Nation never put crossing over as the movement. It’s easy to forget what an influence Tip and their cohorts had on the game in terms of driving the sound of Hip-Hop: you can hear the circle closing throughout The Renaissance. The sound of the album, from the opening jazz bass-driven “Johnny is Dead,” recalls the sound of the earlier Tribe classics, but it’s in turn influenced by the cleaner, more accessible production styles of Kanye and Just Blaze. The best tracks, like “Official,” mish-mash these styles so fluidly, that it almost overwhelms the MCing.
The album maintains a strong party vibe throughout. “Move,” flips a Jackson 5 sample into a driving dance track. Q-Tip sounds much more comfortable over this type of party track, and appeals to get asses on floors don’t sound like selling out. If partying isn’t the theme of the track, then positivity is still close to the surface. “Gettin’ Up’s” seductive appeal is directed at a mythical lady, but the piano keys and Q-Tip’s choral appeal “today is nice, you know we gettin’ up” can easily be extended to America in general. No doubt Q-Tip was prescient choosing to release the LP on November 4th.
Lyrically, Q-Tip’s ability has slipped a half-step from his peak days. Never the most authoritative, his vocal tone has risen slightly, and the monotone on songs like “Won’t Trade,” will bore the uninitiated. He peppers his rhymes with fewer moments of biting humor than in the past, perhaps in an effort to maintain the positive vibe. At the same time, he’s still levels above much of the garbage out there today, unafraid to discuss mature topics like conflict in relationship, as heard on “You.” The extended metaphor of “We Fight/We Love,” a track on the surface about a man leaving his woman to join the army, but that can be applied to the Hip-Hop generation’s obsession with violence, proves you can make poetry out of topics other than the crack trade.
Present too in Tip’s lyrics is a condescending tone towards Hip-Hop today. From the album’s title (the re-birth,) to shots at current rappers on “Dance on Glass,” it’s clear he thinks the game’s done changed, and not for the better. He’s probably right, and if this album won’t get things back on track, it can at least serve as a reminder that they are multiple approaches that can produce good albums. Whether anyone under 25 will get the chance to hear, or care if they do, is another question entirely.



Damn the TSS 3 and 1/2 cigs = The Colored C+ that racist professors gave the black students. As long as you rhyme you get 31/2 cigs. LOL!!!
Seriously, it was a fair review of Q-Tip’s latest project.
Again
We don’t make the music lol.
40 degree days out this motherfucker.
Respect the opinions of the crew, but (to me) if this album’s not a 4 it’s a 3.5 w/ extra tobacco & a smallish filter on a 51 degree day.
I can see a younger cat missin’ the boat on a lot of the tracks, but ‘Gettin’ Up’ is an exceptional cut, and ‘You’, my personal favorite, manages to effectively say a whole lot in a very minimalist fashion – Q-Tip’s specialty.
Definitely exceeded the expectations I had.
Cosign Gotty to the nth power.
I still copped it though..
3.5
Along with NAS this is my choice hip hop album of the year, sure beats woeful Jansport rucksack stuff like Wack Milk, Rip Off Exchange and Slurs.
4 out of 5 in my humble opinion, beats, rhymes, life.
I like that Nintendo powerglove that Q-Tip is sporting on the cover too.
…’kamaal da abstract’ lp ,iz fo december.?.
nah Surely for the end of tha 1st quarter 2009…
I Hope.
to the 4.0 !
3.5 is the gold standard around these parts, huh? Fuck it, I liked this album because it’s different than most shit I’m hearing right about now.
@ Baby Paw: Are you serious my ninja??? For real B.
@ Patrick M: Hiphop ain’t no young man’s game, you just have to know who you’re catering to. That’s the problem with some of the more “mature” artists; they get caught up in trying to appeal to the teen crowd instead of just making the music that they like. Nas is a good example of an artist that has been around, but continues to do it his way, yet still appeals to all.
500k Flea, yeah serious, I give it 4 out 5. It does the basics right and that is what counts, the running length is just about right, good sequencing with the tracks, nice beats and rhymes. It gets the job done, this and the NAS album for me.
I’ll take the Q-Tip album over Foreign Exchange, MURS and Black Milk any time of the day.
It’s fresh, you can pump it in the ride, on your home stereo system on your ipod at your work place desk stop. It’s got good versatility value.
Maybe I’m slightly biased because I grew up on Tribe, but hey this album sounds fresh to me, the ladies seem to dig it and even non hip hop heads who I given it a listen to, like the sound of it.
It’s f-f-f-fresh.
I kinda think y’all overrated this joint slightly.
3 Cigs…& a bust down.
I wasn’t overly impressed with Q-Tip lyrically. I dig the production but a few tracks are sorta boring. I’m a huge Tribe fan & after the long wait, I just wanted Tip to say a little more.
It’s kinda hard (NH) to say this but…
The Renaisance = Amplified
Aside from a couple standouts (ie. Getting Up, We Fight/We Love, Life is Better, Johnny Is Dead & Shaka), I wasn’t overly impressed. In fact, I dig the sound of “Amplified” a little more than what Tip did on this one. It’s not a dud but with Q-Tip’s pedigree, I expected more.
@ OED
I feel you but giving this 4 Cigs would have been a bit of a stretch given that no songs really act like like a heavyweight by themselves. Good, solid, fluid album.
Best of the year? Are you kidding me?
LOL @ Amp
Remember, 3.5 is a pretty good rating people.
@ Baby Paw: I feel you (no homo) in regard to the Q-Tip album, it is dope, but to say that the artists you aforementioned are wack is kind of a stretch my dude.
ps: 88-Keys tomorrow!!!
I’ll take the Q-Tip album over Foreign Exchange
======================================
Nah B.
man, this album was in my CD player almost as much as my favorite albums so far (T.I. & Jeezy), I dug the production, but I feel you lyrically Tip didn’t go as far a he used to, not like he was awful, on his worst day he got plies in a chokehold, but not all that.
i dug this way more than “Amplified”, it was more cohesive than “Amplified”. honestly that was what i was worried about when he said he was releasing this, “don’t be as bad as Amplified.”
@ TC
No doubt, mayne. I even feel somewhat funny standing on the soapbox and saying it’s the ‘skrawngest’ 4 on the 5 cig scale. This is one of those albums that could’ve been better (the strong 4 range), but has enough ‘real life’ themes to garner a bit more longevity than the average 3.5 album would.
3.75 is splitting hairs, but would probably be accurate in this instance.
This could very well just be my perception that a 3.5 pretty much signifies a ‘take it or leave it’ album, and I think this one is better than that.
*Note: I’m also a LOYAL Tribe head, so I may be biased.
3.5 cigs? Seriously?
Excellent album, but I prefer “Amplified.” That shit was underrated and it has aged really well. People just overreacted to the imagery that came along with the album.
“You,” “Move,” “Gettin Up” and “Dance On Glass” are amazing tracks.
Was this album more cohesive than “Amplified”? Yeah, but “Amplified” had way better production overall. And like TC said… “no songs really act like like a heavyweight by themselves.”
“Getting Up” is cool, but there is no “Vivrant Thing” or “Breathe & Stop” on this album. Not that those songs were really great, but you can’t stunt on Dilla’s beats. Tip shoulda reached out & got some other producers on here. Doing the lion’s share of the album is admirable but hints of a huge ego too.
And to clarify
3 Cigs…& a bustdown = 3.25
Or just round down & give it a 3.
Eff it, I said it lol.
*dodges rotten tomato*
@ Baby Paw
“It’s fresh, you can pump it in the ride, on your home stereo system on your ipod at your work place desk stop. It’s got good versatility value.”
—————————
good point.
…And I still bought it.
@ OED
This, and that Pete Rock are good examples of “3.75s” but usually all that’s doing is factoring a stronger personal preference. As the review states:
Whether anyone under 25 will get the chance to hear, or care if they do, is another question entirely
If this was truly a 4, it wouldn’t range so many mixed emotions by so many different audiences.
LMAO @ Amp
no you didn’t take it back to the rotten tomato era ’round here. LOL
I still got a surplus, AND I KNOW TC has some leftovers.
*makes note to self to stock up on more tomatoes*
^ LOL
@ TC
gotcha.
that makes sense, and clarifies the ratings system a lot more for me.
next task- figuring out the NFL QB ratings system, and college football rankings.
aight, I’m watching VH1 Soul right now, and Prince’s “U Got The Look” is on…Prince was a bad muthafucka.
how the fuck did he pull all that ass?
lol’ short light-skinneded muthafucka…I need HIS game
It’s the heels Teef, gotta be the heels lol.
All these varying opinions, and for varying reasons, just go to show that the shit isn’t an exact science. What it does is kinda give people a diff take on things so they might hear it differently
so keep yappin.
Good review and in my opinion, accurate score. My university’s newspaper actually gave this a 4 1/2 out of 5 which I thought was too generous.
Regardless, this has been a staple in my listening for the past three weeks. “Official” is hands down my favorite track on the album.
“Whether anyone under 25 will get the chance to hear, or care if they do, is another question entirely.”
Well, there’s at least one under 25 (and even under 20) that hears and cares.
The Renaisance = Amplified
=======================
C’mon Amp… Amplified was butt IMO. I gave this joint 4 cigs. Good review though.
Ayo dun, ya’knowhatimsayin. What you, y’knawmsayin, tryin to say about my, yknawmsayin, singles, dun? Polow Da Don, yknawmsayin, he’s the future, dunny. And Chris Brown, dun. He’s, yknawmsayin, the new – hol up, i need ta re-light this mu’fucka. Anyway. yknawmsayin, he’s the new Mike Jack, dun.
Yo, if you’re lookin for another Tribe record, you will be disappointed……so many tribe fans won’t let these cats go. Same thing happened with Amplified and, really, all the post -Low End Theory Tribe records. Everyone wanted Midnight Maurauders to be Low End Theory 2. And it wasn’t til a couple years later that cats appreciated MM and now it seems to be considered the best of the Tribe records. Same thing happened with Beats Rhymes & Life. Had the most hype of any of the tribe records, but everyone was disappointed when it dropped. Today folks are like, that’s a classic – Jay Dilla’s breakthrough and whatnot. But heads really just didn’t like it initially cuz it wasn’t MM2.
Amplified caught hate cuz the visuals seemed to be caught up in the jiggy movement, which was very anti-tribe. But y’know, I think that was the point. Go back and listen to that shit, it’s better than you remember.
This, to me, is the best Tribe-related record since BR&L. That was an album I liked a lot. Though I wouldn’t quite call it a classic like albums 2 & 3. The Love Movement was ill too, but off the initial couple of listens, I like this better. Same with Amplified.
I like the way the album flows. The first time i turned it on, I listened to it and it ended before i noticed. That’s usually the sign of a good record, when you’re constantly having to look at what song is next, etc – it usually means the record is boring you or isn’t moving well. This record doesn’t do that. And it has a distinct feel. It’s more De La-ish than Tribe-ish. In that, it has a sound and all the guest artists kind of join Tip’s planet, instead of him catering to their sounds. I’d give it 4 stars. It’s probably a top 3 album of the year. Though at the moment, i haven’t decided what my favorite hip hop albums are this year. There haven’t been enough that i’ve actually liked. Hopefully the fourth quarter will interest me more. I’ve only really given TI and Nas rotation this year. With some Immortal Technique mixed in there. Jeezy’s and Game’s albums were good but were mixed bags to me. They had some really dope ishhh but they also had some serious filler. And both albums got boring to go through repeated times. Jeezy just has too many songs that sound the same, and Game has too many different sounds.
To me it’s been much more of an R&B year. Dwele, Foreign Exchange, Raheem DeVaughn, even the pop cats – Ne-Yo and Lloyd each dropped good albums. Erykah Badu, Gnarles Barkley, etc.
Thashyt, some good points you have raised there.
I’ll admit that I didn’t like Amplified straightaway, however, as per what some folks have stated already, managed to revisit that album again a few years down the line and yeah it kind of grew on me.
The Renaissance, on the other hand got my attention almost immediately, I deem it to be a very well concocted album. It’s a good progression of over Amplified, me thinks.
I think a couple of years down the line more heads will appreciate this album so much more, Beats, Rhymes, Life back in 1996 didn’t garner too much kudos initially. However, it would seem that a few years down the line more and more people opened up towards how decent that album actually is.
I would say that amongst a sea of trite and mundane hip hop releases this year, Q-Tip is one of the few sets that feels like a breath of fresh air.
Along with NAS this is my choice hip hop album of the year, sure beats woeful Jansport rucksack stuff like Wack Milk, Rip Off Exchange and Slurs.
4 out of 5 in my humble opinion, beats, rhymes, life.
———————————————————————————————–
All I can say is “WOW”
Nursery rhyme niggas who frontin like crime figures!
Tip brought that classic NYC hiphop on this album, I bumped this all year but its a good spring/summer record !