For someone who probably won’t get alot of shine in major media outlets, Madlib’s had a prolific career. Having collaborated with everyone from MF Doom to Talib Kweli, he’s rivaled all but Kool Keith in terms of putting out albums, mixtapes, collaborations, or instrumental. The bevy of work hasn’t translated into mainstream accolades, but it has earned him respect and name recognition within Hip-Hop underground and internet communities.
At the same time, putting out a new project every four months almost guarantees some of the matierial will not be up to standards (See: Bone Thugs.) Such is the case with Madlib’s latest LP, WLIB AM: King of the Wigflip. The album is a mish-mash of samples, instrumental segments and occasional full-length songs that doesn’t have the consistent level of high-quality musical innovation to make up for its fragmented nature.
The high points of the album are the collaborations. “What It Do” features Talib Kweli outshining every other guest on the album with a typical thought rumination on the world and people around us. The best track is “Gamble On Your Boy” featuring Defari. The monotone battle rhymes meld perfectly with Madlib’s big bass and funky horns. Other tracks, like “The Thang-Thang” assisted by Prince Po and the fierce “I Want It Back,” build on this theme of retro Hip-Hop beats and rhymes that could have been the foundation of a successful album.
Unfortunately, at 24 tracks, there is too much filler that make the listener reach for the fast forward button. Maybe “Disco Dance,” would be good at a rave, but sober it lags while “Tension,” sounds like a bad Nintendo soundtrack. These parts of the album are DJ Shadow gone awry; an artist’s attempt to create piece together beautiful music out of noise that falls flat.
With so much time devoted to uninteresting musical experimentation, it’s difficult to stay focused or engaged with the album. At the lowest points, it descends into the unlistenable. “Blindfold Test # 10,” with its disharmonic horns and a piercingly irritating vocal alarm clock sound effect, is the most egregious example. But at least irritation is a reaction: the real problem with WLIB is that too many of the beats and rhymes are boring.
Madlib tries to push the envelope, but does not display the mastery or creativity needed to do so. In the end, an album must be judged on the quality of its content, and, like many radio stations out there, WLIB AM just doesn’t have enough of it.



Hey Patrick! HOW THE FUCK YOU SOUND?!?!?! Fuck the maintream!!!! King of the Wigflip is PURE DOPE. YOU don’t know what the fuck YOUR’E talking about?!?!?
It’s folks like YOU that believe if a album sells like hotcakes make sit a classic that is not always the case.
Your review sucks major cat ass!!!!
Fuck the Mainstream!!!!!!
lmao @ “sucks major cat ass”
Must be a slow down in the cpu lab.
I failed to see anywhere in the review which indicated “mainstream” was better. This album is just simply subpar. And just because it doesn’t sound like the mainstream, it’s supposed to be better? Fucc outta here!
LOL at “sucks major cat ass” and ARBitraRY cAPS loCK
OT: It’s funny how the sports media is trashing Vince Young right now and conveniently forgets that Kerri Collins was an alcoholic racist with the DUIs and ass whoopings to prove it.
Fair enough. I agree with the standout selections and I haven’t listened to anything else off the album since it dropped. Disappointing effort, given the talent.
Lol @ “Must be a slow down in the cpu lab”
It’s fun to profile people based on their comments here
I bet when The Cheetah Girls is on the Disney Channel in Gotty’s house, he has just as much “fun” watching as his keikis
I was diligently going to Best Buy every other day looking to buy this…guess I won’t anymore.
The TSS Crew reviews are THAT powerful & influential.
blow the horns on em!!!!!
2.5? really? ll cool j’s new album is better? really? nelly’s new album is better? jeezys? termanologys? this album is about equal to dj khaleds last album?
really?
^sooo…you LIKE this album? Hmm…hating on the review would be the same as liking the album, right? So by default you would have to be liking something? Quite the conundrum eh Mr. Chris?
Hahahaha first time in life I agree with Chris.
Pat, your write up is great and well written. But I’d have to disagree whole-heartedly with the review. Madlib’s style has always been about an ecclectic array of sounds and mash-ups… this doesn’t deviate from his signature sound.
^ True dat L 2 da Sea
FYE, Teef
Album is dope to me. On my 1st listen at the J-O, the beats are bananas, some get a little Jay Dee-ish, like the 2 where he uses the front half of a dilla sample on 1 curt then the 2nd half on another cut. The emcees, you get what you get, but it’s typical Madlib to me. His chop game is serious.
^^^ No LC Weber
Chris flipped lol.
Yes, Jeezy’s album > this.
Enh…I haven’t listened to the album as a whole so I can’t weigh in. But i’ve never been a huge Madlib fan.
I didn’t even like doing Madlibs as a kid so just his name alone turns me off lol
This album didn’t really hit the target much for me at all, but then Madlib’s always been a patchy producer at best – that’s not meant as an insult – when he’s good he’s superb, but he’s put out a lot of skillfully produced yet ultimately unsatisfactory music in his time.
best track on the album – Yo Yo Affair
Gotty gettin’ literary on you fools. Guess ML won’t be commentin’ up in here like Jaycee and Phonte…
Down goes another artist shot down in the TSS Corral.
I think DX emptied the clip uptop. not sure if he hit a target, but he was squeezin’ hard.
@ One-Eyed Deer: thanks…if I’m pressed to cop it after giving it a spin, I just might go to FYE..unlikely though, cuz I’m real particular about getting my Reward Zone points @ Best Buy, lol
“The album is a mish-mash of samples, instrumental segments and occasional full-length songs that doesn’t have the consistent level of high-quality musical innovation to make up for its fragmented nature.”
======================================================
@ Patrick M.
This statement makes me feel like you haven’t really ever heard any of Madlib’s work prior to WLIB. Every album produced by Madlib in its entirety (ex: Madvillain’s or Quasimoto’s) is what you described. Minus the “doesn’t have the consistent level of high-quality musical innovation” part, this is what people expect from Madlib. Not to mention the album is supposed to be a BBE Beat Generation release. Check J Dilla, DJ Spinna, or Pete Rock’s original Petestrumentals.
Trust TSS Fam, if you liked a majority of Madlib’s work before this, you won’t be disappointed by the this.
Yeah I couldn’t disagree more with this album. Dude, you liked “Gamble on Ya Boy”? That’s track is horrible, I skip that every time. And “Blindfold Test” is pretty poorly executed as well, but that’s by J-Rocc. In fact, and maybe this is just me, but I felt lib should’ve incorporated more of a radio feel to it. And that crackly fuzzy shit at the start of some tracks makes me skip them. Oh an that “Tension” instrumental is the shit.
BUT lol, all that aside I definitely felt like there were some good tracks on here to ride with. Without looking at the tracklisting:
“What it Do”
“I want it Back”
“The Ox”
“Take that Money”
“Drinks Up!”
“Go!”
“Blow the Horns on ‘em”
Even those RnB tracks I can tolerate at the right time. You know, those ones with Frenza and Stacy Epps. Believe me, it was well worth the coppin.
couldn’t disagree more with this review* LOL my bad
This album got the same rating as DJ Khaled’s album. That alone proves that you cats need to seriously either overhaul your ratings system or just refrain from reviewing certain underground Hip Hop albums altogether.
Patrick’s argument as to why this album “sucked” are bullshit. If you gave this argument in terms of Madlib’s Movie Scenes or Beat Konducta series’ where it’s 20 tracks between 45 seconds and 2 minutes each I’d understand but you clearly have no idea what to even look/listen as far as Madlib is concerned.
There is NO way this release deserves a 2.5 cig rating. None whatsoever. TSS is dropping the ball in the reviews category in my opinion.
One.
dart –
if TSS is “dropping the ball” with their reviews, why waste the time saying so?
i check for madlib and i consider myself a fan of his production style – therefore i know to expect the unexpected, so to speak. its because of (not despite) his track record that i was eager to hear WLIB. but while i disagree with “gamble on ya boy” being a worthy cut, i wholeheartedly agree with this review. “what it do”, “the OX”, and “go!” are standouts, but i feel like madlib either came up short, gave BBE a throwaway album, or made sure that he saved his best efforts for the dill cosby/dill withers series.
co-sign teefh, TSS ratings make or break an album for me and a LOT of the fam ’round here – just as your site, dart, opened my eyes to certain artists and movies. but to straight shit on how the crew rates albums makes you sound rather bitter.
beat konducta 5 and 6 fire
king of the wigflip almost total garbo
Go back & listen to the album again. This time around…..TURN DAT $H*T UP!!!!!! “Madlib is the ILLEST, my n……”
The fact that Hater Chris likes the album, hell likes anything the album should get 5 cigs, a cuban cigar, and a Redman rolled philly blunt!!!
But cats really need to get off all the foolishness. Just how you have an opinion, the reveiwer has an opinion as well. Who cares if any reveiwer doesn’t like what you like; all that matters is that you enjoy it.
@ Levar FM:
Even when I HATE something or I just don’t like it I insist that the reader make their own decision ultimately. By flat out giving a quality album the same rating you’d give…let’s say a DJ Khaled, Big Kuntry King or Blood Raw album is borderline bullshit and needs to be seriously looked at. This album would have to be TERRIBLE to deserve a 2.5 and it just wasn’t in any way imaginable.
Is it a classic? Hell nah. Is it wack? Hell fuckin’ nah!
That is all.
@ Dart
By now it’s obvious what you’re preference is in Hip-Hop. But just because you personally feel Hip-Hop was better when b-boys ruled the world doesn’t make any other regions any less capable of making quality.
2.5=Just average. Obviously you’re a stickler and a believe in “real Hip-Hop” which is fine and dandy but one day you’re gonna have to ask yourself why you’re always on the outside lookin’ in.
Two.
“one day you’re gonna have to ask yourself why you’re always on the outside lookin’ in.”
^ ooooooooohhh, moded!
@ TC
There is no such thing as “Real Hip Hop”, just “Hip Hop”. Whether you’re from Paris, France or Oxnard, CA or Marietta, GA or Philadelphia, PA or New York, NY you either make Hip Hop music or you don’t. Period. You obviously read more into what I wrote than I was even thinking about.
I’m always on the outside lookin’ in because I that’s the kind of person I am, period. I’m the same way with film and everything else you would consider to be art or an artform. Is that a bad thing or something? I don’t think it is.
One.
First, I’m glad to see that kind of stuff having some words around TSS…
Madlib deserve more coverage here, on this blogged almighty rap temple…
I haven’t heard the album yet, but Otis Jr. is one if not my favorite producer since he started doing it…
To me, a true mastermind just like RZA…
And you know, even RZA can sound boring from time to time, but dude is still one the best, just like Madlib cannot be the shit everytime…
I gotta agree with the cat ass sucking vibe of this review.
New Madlib, we all know what the bizness is…smoke somethin!
Obviously you’re a stickler and a believe in “real Hip-Hop” which is fine and dandy but one day you’re gonna have to ask yourself why you’re always on the outside lookin’ in.
Hey TC!
Like he’s the only one.Its a rack of us outside.
why the fuck do you say “Madlib tried to push the envelope”? Because he obviously didn’t try. He has on other occasions.
blindfold test is the standout on this one–pure madlib. why you hoggin dog pass that!